Toronto vs Columbus Crew — result, stats and line-ups

Full Time

2024

TorontoEastern Conference · 12.

19 SEPT

0:2

Columbus CrewEastern Conference · 13.

Goals

GOAL

AST

Goal51'

Cucho Hernández (assist: Jacen Russell-Rowe) 0-1

GOAL

AST

Goal70'

Andrés Herrera (assist: Cucho Hernández) 0-2

Man of the match

Patrick SchulteColumbus Crew7.8

Expected goals (xG)

TorontoxGColumbus Crew

0.890.92

AI forecast

Tippio

The AI forecast opens in the Tippio app

An AI subscription opens everything. You can also earn it by tipping: tip at least 70% of a league's matches in a week and next week it's yours for free. A single outcome opens by watching an ad. Sign in and it shows here too, if you have access.

Get the app

TV stations

International

Bet365

TSN4

TSN1

RDS App

YouTube

Channels in 2 countries

Canada

TSN4

TSN1

RDS App

International

Bet365

YouTube

Venue

Toronto Stadium

Conditions

Weatherovercast clouds
RefereeGuido Gonzalez
1st AssistantLyes Arfa
2nd AssistantGianni Facchini
4th OfficialLukasz Szpala

Pressure index

TorontoColumbus Crew

1′45′90′

Which side was pressing, minute by minute. The markers are the events: tap one to read the minute and the player — and, with ball positions loaded, the replay jumps there.

Match flow

OUT

Substitution46'

In: Cucho Hernández · Out: Diego Rossi

OUT

Substitution46'

In: Tyrese Spicer · Out: Jonathan Osorio · Substitution because of injury

GOAL

AST

Goal51'

Cucho Hernández (assist: Jacen Russell-Rowe) 0-1

OUT

Substitution66'

In: Max Arfsten · Out: DeJuan Jones

OUT

Substitution66'

In: AZ Jackson · Out: Jacen Russell-Rowe

OUT

Substitution70'

In: Kosi Thompson · Out: Lorenzo Insigne · Substitution because of injury

GOAL

AST

Goal70'

Andrés Herrera (assist: Cucho Hernández) 0-2

PLAYER

Yellow card78'

Richie Laryea · Argument

PLAYER

Yellow card79'

Federico Bernardeschi · Foul

OUT

Substitution82'

In: Prince Owusu · Out: Deandre Kerr

OUT

Substitution82'

In: Brandon Servania · Out: Matty Longstaff

PLAYER

Yellow card85'

Derrick Jones · Foul

OUT

Substitution86'

In: Alexandru Mățan · Out: Dylan Chambost

PLAYER

Yellow card90'

Alexandru Mățan · Time wasting

OUT

Substitution90'

In: Yaw Yeboah · Out: Derrick Jones · Substitution because of injury

Ball positions

The ball's path over the whole match or one half: press play to run through it, drag the slider to jump anywhere. Loaded on request to keep the page light.

Commentary

And that's it. The match concludes - Toronto FC 0, Columbus Crew 2.
90+7′The second half concludes with Columbus Crew leading Toronto FC by 2 goals to 0.
90+7′Offside called against Columbus Crew. Max Arfsten is caught in an offside position.
90+5′Missed chance. Kosi Thompson - Toronto FC - shot with the head from the centre of the box missed to the left. Assist - Federico Bernardeschi with a cross after corner.
90+4′Corner kick awarded to Toronto FC, forced by Malte Amundsen.
90+4′Another offensive effort. Alonso Coello of Toronto FC takes a challenging left-footed shot from the left side, but it's deflected in the top left corner. The assist came from Federico Bernardeschi with a cross pass.
90+3′Corner kick awarded to Toronto FC, due to a deflection off Max Arfsten.
90+3′Pause ended. They are prepared to proceed.
90+3′Player swap for Columbus Crew. Derrick Jones, due to an injury, is being replaced by Yaw Yeboah.
90+2′Match interruption - Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew is injured.
90+1′Opportunity squandered. Aziel Jackson of Columbus Crew attempts a left-footed shot from beyond the box, but it sails high and wide to the left. The assist was provided by Andrés Herrera.
90+1′The fourth referee has declared an additional 5 minutes of playtime.
90′Yevhen Cheberko of Columbus Crew is penalized for a handball.
90′Alexandru Matan of Columbus Crew has been handed a yellow card.
89′Corner kick awarded to Columbus Crew, forced by Sigurd Rosted's defensive play.
89′Attempt thwarted. Cucho Hernández of Columbus Crew's right-footed shot from the middle of the box is stopped. Aziel Jackson provided the assist.
87′Corner kick awarded to Columbus Crew, forced by Richie Laryea.
86′Opportunity squandered. Federico Bernardeschi of Toronto FC takes a left-footed shot from beyond the penalty area following a free kick, but it sails over the crossbar.Penalty
85′Player Swap - Columbus Crew. Dylan Chambost is being replaced by Alexandru Matan.
85′Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew has been handed a yellow card for committing a foul.
85′Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew has committed a foul.
85′Alonso Coello of Toronto FC has been awarded an offensive free kick.
84′Sean Zawadzki of Columbus Crew has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
84′Alonso Coello of Toronto FC commits a foul.
83′Offside - Tyrese Spicer of Toronto FC has been flagged offside.
82′Player swap - Toronto FC. Prince Osei Owusu is coming on to replace Deandre Kerr.
82′Player change - Toronto FC. Matty Longstaff is being replaced by Brandon Servania.
82′Max Arfsten of Columbus Crew is penalized for a handball.
80′Matty Longstaff of Toronto FC has earned a defensive free kick.
80′Aziel Jackson of Columbus Crew has committed a foul.
78′Federico Bernardeschi of Toronto FC has been shown a yellow card.
78′Richie Laryea of Toronto FC has been handed a yellow card for committing a foul.
78′Richie Laryea of Toronto FC commits a foul.
78′Aziel Jackson of Columbus Crew has earned a free kick on the left flank.
77′Opportunity squandered. Dylan Chambost of Columbus Crew took a left-footed shot from the middle of the box, but it veered off to the left. The assist was provided by Cucho Hernández.
76′Sean Zawadzki of Columbus Crew has successfully secured a defensive free kick.
76′Toronto FC's Richie Laryea commits a foul.
75′Corner kick awarded to Toronto FC, forced by Yevhen Cheberko.
70′Score! Toronto FC 0, Columbus Crew 2. Andrés Herrera of Columbus Crew strikes with his right foot from the middle of the box, sending the ball into the right corner. The assist came from Cucho Hernández with a well-placed through ball.
70′Player change for Toronto FC. Kosi Thompson is coming on to replace Lorenzo Insigne due to an injury.
66′Player change - Columbus Crew. Aziel Jackson is coming on to replace Jacen Russell-Rowe.
66′Player change - Columbus Crew. Max Arfsten is coming on to replace DeJuan Jones.
65′Corner kick awarded to Toronto FC, forced by Cucho Hernández.
63′Corner kick awarded to Toronto FC, thanks to Yevhen Cheberko's defensive action.
63′Attempt thwarted. Derrick Etienne Jr. of Toronto FC's right-footed shot from the right side of the box is intercepted. The assist was by Deandre Kerr.
59′Offside called - Toronto FC. Deandre Kerr has been flagged offside.
54′Matty Longstaff from Toronto FC has secured a free kick on the left flank.
54′Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew has committed a foul.
54′Jacen Russell-Rowe of Columbus Crew has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
54′Raoul Petretta commits a foul - Toronto FC.
53′Attempt thwarted. Federico Bernardeschi of Toronto FC's left-footed strike from the right side of the penalty area is intercepted. The assist came from Derrick Etienne Jr.Penalty
51′Score! Toronto FC 0, Columbus Crew 1. Cucho Hernández of Columbus Crew fires a right-footed shot from beyond the box into the top right corner. The assist was provided by Jacen Russell-Rowe.
51′Offside call - Toronto FC. Deandre Kerr has been flagged offside.
50′Another offensive effort. Sean Zawadzki of Columbus Crew takes a shot with his right foot from beyond the box, but it's deflected to the right corner. The assist was by Dylan Chambost.
46′Richie Laryea of Toronto FC has successfully secured a defensive free kick.
46′Cucho Hernández commits a foul - Columbus Crew.
45′Player swap - Toronto FC. Tyrese Spicer is coming on for Jonathan Osorio due to an injury.
45′Player change - Columbus Crew. Diego Rossi is replaced by Cucho Hernández.
45′The second half kicks off with Toronto FC and Columbus Crew still at a stalemate, 0-0.
45+2′The first half concludes with both Toronto FC and Columbus Crew yet to score, standing at 0-0.
45+1′The fourth referee has declared an extra time of two minutes.
43′Matty Longstaff commits a foul - Toronto FC.
43′Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew successfully earned a defensive free kick.
42′Richie Laryea of Toronto FC has successfully secured a defensive free kick.
42′Diego Rossi commits a foul against Columbus Crew.
41′Sigurd Rosted of Toronto FC has successfully earned a free kick on the right flank.
41′Dylan Chambost of Columbus Crew has committed a foul.
40′Federico Bernardeschi of Toronto FC has committed a foul.
40′DeJuan Jones of Columbus Crew has successfully secured a defensive free kick.
38′Another offensive move. Lorenzo Insigne of Toronto FC makes a right-footed shot from the left side of the box, but it's saved at the top middle of the goal. The assist was by Derrick Etienne Jr...
35′Another offensive effort. Andrés Herrera of Columbus Crew takes a right-footed shot from the right side of the box, but the goalkeeper makes a save right in the middle of the goal.
33′Attempt thwarted. Federico Bernardeschi of Toronto FC strikes with his left foot from the right side of the penalty area, but the shot is stopped. The pass was provided by Richie Laryea.Penalty
31′Pause has ended. They are prepared to resume.
30′Match interruption - Jonathan Osorio of Toronto FC is injured.
30′Lorenzo Insigne of Toronto FC has been awarded a free kick in the offensive zone.
30′Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew commits a foul.
26′Rudy Camacho commits a foul - Columbus Crew.
26′Deandre Kerr of Toronto FC has successfully secured a defensive free kick.
23′Opportunity squandered. Jonathan Osorio of Toronto FC attempted a header from the middle of the box but didn't succeed. The assist was by Derrick Etienne Jr. who provided a cross.
23′Attempt thwarted. Richie Laryea from Toronto FC's left-footed strike from beyond the box gets obstructed.
22′Another offensive effort. Lorenzo Insigne of Toronto FC takes a shot with his right foot from the middle of the box, but it's saved in the right corner. The assist comes from Federico Bernardeschi.
21′Deandre Kerr from Toronto FC commits a foul.
21′Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
20′Derrick Jones of Columbus Crew has committed a foul.
20′Derrick Etienne Jr. of Toronto FC has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
18′Richie Laryea of Toronto FC has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
18′DeJuan Jones from Columbus Crew has committed a foul.
15′Lorenzo Insigne commits a foul - Toronto FC.
15′Diego Rossi - Columbus Crew - won a free kick on the right wing.
12′Diego Rossi of Columbus Crew is penalized for a handball.
11′Offside call - Columbus Crew. Jacen Russell-Rowe has been flagged for offside.
10′A new offensive move is underway. Lorenzo Insigne of Toronto FC takes a shot with his right foot from beyond the box, but the goalkeeper manages to save it in the middle of the goal. The assist was provided by Alonso Coello.
8′Offside called against Columbus Crew. Jacen Russell-Rowe has been flagged for being offside.
7′Federico Bernardeschi of Toronto FC strikes the crossbar with a left-footed shot from the right side of the box. The assist was provided by Alonso Coello.
2′Offside call - Columbus Crew. Diego Rossi has been flagged offside.
2′Rudy Camacho commits a foul - Columbus Crew.
2′Deandre Kerr of Toronto FC has earned a free kick on the left flank.
The initial half of the match commences..

Match statistics

TORCOL

Possession and passing

50%Possession50%

85%Pass accuracy85%

492Passes498

423Successful Passes424

60Ball Safe69

10Key Passes6

3 more

7Long Passes5

4Substitutions5

3Throw-ins5

Attack

0Goals2

12Shots Total7

4Shots On Target4

5Corners2

42Dangerous Attacks37

3Accurate Crosses0

11 more

81Attacks81

12Dribble Attempts13

7Goal Attempts6

3Offsides4

4Shots Blocked1

9Shots inside the box4

4Shots Off Target2

3Shots outside the box3

100%Successful dribbles50%

3Successful Dribbles1

13Total Crosses4

Defence and discipline

3Saves4

17Tackles14

12Interceptions10

8Fouls14

2Yellow cards2

5Goal Kicks9

Other

1Hit Woodwork0

3Successful Interceptions3

1Challenges2

1Injuries1

The halves are each period's own numbers — not a split of the full-time figures.

The referee

G. GonzalezPer-match averages this season · 23 matches · career: 137

	Avg	Home	Away	Career
Yellow cards	4.87	2.26	2.61	4.59
Red cards	0.04	0.04	0.00	0.14
Second yellows	0.04	0.00	0.04	0.08
Penalties	0.35	0.26	0.09	0.27

Home / away: what the home and the away side received on average. Career: the average over every match officiated.

Expected goals (xG)

TorontoxGColumbus Crew

0.890.92

Expected Goals on Target (xGoT)

1.161.04

Expected Goals Non Penalty Goals (npxG)

0.890.92

Expected Goals Open Play (xGOP)

0.700.92

Expected Goals Set Play (xGSP)

0.190.00

Expected Goals Corners (xGC)

0.130.00

Expected Goals Free Kicks (xGFK)

0.060.00

Expected Points (xPTS)

1.311.36

Starting XI

Columbus CrewFormation: 3-4-2-1 · €11M8/11

Wilfried Nancy

TorontoFormation: 3-4-2-1 · €42M5/11

John Herdman

The ↓ and minute under a player mean they were substituted off then.

Transfer fees

Toronto€42Mstarting XI · 5/11€43Mwith bench · 9/20

Columbus Crew€11Mstarting XI · 8/11€37Mwith bench · 16/20

Toronto's starting XI cost €31M more.

The amount under a player is their last known transfer fee and its year (provider data) — not a market value.

Toronto — bench

Aimé MabikaDefender · €91K (2023)16

Tyrese SpicerAttacker · €430K (2025)6.7 19

Kobe FranklinDefender20

Deybi FloresMidfielder · €100K (2023)23

Brandon ServaniaMidfielder6.5 47

Kosi ThompsonMidfielder6.6 90

Luka GavranGoalkeeper95

Nathaniel EdwardsDefender99

Prince OwusuAttacker · €245K (2025)6.9

Columbus Crew — bench

Nicholas HagenGoalkeeper6

Darlington NagbeMidfielder · €954K (2019)9

Cucho HernándezAttacker · €13M (2025)8.3 13

AZ JacksonMidfielder · €606K (2024)7.1 14

Yaw YeboahMidfielder · €1.8M (2022)17

Christian RamirezAttacker · €240K (2025)20

Alexandru MățanMidfielder · €1.5M (2021)6.6 27

Max ArfstenMidfielder · €6.5M (2026)6.8 31

Steven MoreiraDefender · €1.2M (2016)

Player statistics

Toronto starters then subs, by rating

Alonso Coello#14 · Midfielder · 90′7.5

In this match

Attack

Goals: 0
Assists: 0
Shots: 1
Shots on target: 1
Big chances created: 2
Expected goals (xG): 0.06
xGoT: 0.35

Passing

Passes (accurate/total): 59/72
Pass accuracy: 82%
Key passes: 2
Long balls (won/total): 7/12

Possession & duels

Touches: 85
Duels (won/total): 4/6
Dribbles (won/attempted): 1/1
Dispossessed: 1

Defence

Tackles: 2
Interceptions: 1

Discipline

Fouls: 1
Fouls drawn: 1

Player	Reason	Back
Nicksoen Gomis🩹 injury · Hamstring Injury	injury · Hamstring Injury	4 Oct 2024
Henry Wingo🩹 injury · Unknown Injury	injury · Unknown Injury	4 Oct 2024

Player	Reason	Back
Evan Bush🩹 injury · Broken Arm	injury · Broken Arm	19 Feb 2025
Will Sands🩹 injury · Calf Injury	injury · Calf Injury	10 Oct 2024

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Toronto	3.0033.33%	2.9533.9%
Draw	3.5028.57%	3.6027.78%
Columbus Crew	2.2544.44%	2.2344.84%

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Toronto or Draw	1.6161.92%	1.6361.35%
Toronto or Columbus Crew	1.2877.82%	1.2878.13%
Draw or Columbus Crew	1.3673.37%	1.3872.46%

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
2+ goals	–	1.1984.03%
0–1 goals	–	4.6021.74%
3+ goals	1.6660.02%	1.6859.52%
0–2 goals	2.1546.51%	2.1247.17%
4+ goals	–	2.8035.71%
0–3 goals	–	1.4369.93%

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Toronto	3.4029.41%	3.3030.3%
Draw	2.3043.48%	2.3243.1%
Columbus Crew	2.8734.78%	2.6537.74%

Outcome	bet365
TOR → TOR	4.5022.22%
TOR → X	13.007.69%
TOR → COL	23.004.35%
X → TOR	7.0014.29%
X → X	6.0016.67%
X → COL	6.0016.67%
COL → TOR	26.003.85%
COL → X	13.007.69%
COL → COL	3.7526.67%

Outcome	bet365
12 - 14	5.0020%
6 - 8	2.8734.78%
9 - 11	2.6238.1%
Under 6	8.0012.5%
Over 14	13.007.69%

Outcome	bet365
4+ cards	1.6660.02%
0–3 cards	2.1047.62%
5+ cards	2.2045.45%
0–4 cards	1.6161.92%

#	Team	P	Pts
1	Vancouver Whitecaps	25	49
1	Nashville SC	26	57
2	New England	26	46
2	Houston Dynamo	26	44
3	Inter Miami	26	46
3	St. Louis City	26	44
4	Charlotte	26	43
4	Dallas	26	44
5	Chicago Fire	25	39
5	SJ Earthquakes	26	42
6	Los Angeles FC	27	41
6	Philadelphia Union	26	36
7	Orlando City	26	34
7	Colorado Rapids	26	36
8	New York RB	26	33
8	LA Galaxy	27	33
9	Portland Timbers	26	32
9	Cincinnati	25	33
10	Seattle Sounders	25	32
10	New York City	26	32
11	San Diego	26	31
11	DC United	25	29
12	Austin	26	30
12	Toronto	26	29
13	Real Salt Lake	26	29
13	Columbus Crew	26	26
14	Atlanta United	26	26
14	Minnesota United	26	29
15	Sporting KC	25	18
15	CF Montréal	26	21

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Yes	1.5763.65%	1.5564.52%
No	2.2544.44%	2.2843.86%